Only two more powerful..."
by Daishan: 2003-03-30 | Not yet rated
"I cannot trust you fully, Lews Therin. Not yet." She [Lanfear] came closer, and he [Rand] considered simply seizing her. He was bigger and stronger by far - and blocked as he was, she could wrap him up with the Power like a kitten tangled in a ball of string. "Not with that, certainly," she added, grimacing at Callandor. "There are only two more powerful that a man can use. One at least, I know, still exists. No, Lews Therin. I will not trust you yet with that." "Stop calling me that," he growled. "My name is Rand. Rand al'Thor." (TITLE: Shadow Rising, CHAPTER: 9 - Decisions)
Lanfear's remarks to Rand about Callandor; “there are only two more powerful a man can use.” It is generally agreed that the male Choedan Kal is the one Lanfear mentions that "still exists", but the second (sa')angreal remains a mystery for the most part.
However, in tPoD, chapter 2 “Unweaving”, (p. 66 paperback,) Elayne finds:
“The figure of a stout, bearded man with a jolly smile, holding a book; two feet tall, it appeared to be agedarkened bronze and took both of her hands to move.”
While not on a one-to-one scale, size does appear to matter somewhat regarding the strength of angreal/sa'angreal. For instance; Callandor is much bigger than Rand's ‘fat little man', and the Choedan Kal are both much much bigger than that. This man sounds bigger than Callandor. Or maybe “more cumbersome” is better phrasing.
There have been numerous examples of angreal being statues of men or women depending on whether it's male or female. Quotes;
E.g. Moiraine's is a woman in flowing robes;
“Unconsciously he [Rand] leaned back, further away from her [Moiraine] and what she held. A few stories mentioned angreal, those relics of the Age of Legends that Aes Sedai used to perform their greatest wonders. He was startled to see her unwrap a smooth ivory figurine, age-darkened to deep brown. No longer than her hand, it was a woman in flowing robes, with long hair falling about her shoulders.” (TITLE: Eye of the World, CHAPTER: 8 - A Place of Safety)
Elayne's is a naked woman covered in hair,
“The other [angreal] was a seated woman in age-darkened ivory, her legs folded in front of her, her exposed knees bare, but with hair so long and luxuriant she could not have been more muffled in the heaviest cloak.” (TITLE: Path of Daggers CHAPTER: 4 - A Quiet Place)
The Choedan Kal female key is a woman while the male key is a man (both are 'replicas' of the actual huge statues of course), everybody knows how they look so I'll consider that an “established fact”.
Rand's "fat little man" rather speaks for itself too. Interesting other is Bayle Domon; Bayle Domon is (was?) also in possession of a male angreal looking like a man holding a sword:
“Digging into his chest, he [Bayle Domon] set out on the desk what he had bought in Maradon. A lightstick, left from the Age of Legends, or so it was said. Certainly no one knew the making of them any longer. Expensive, that, and rarer than an honest magistrate. It looked like a plain glass rod, thicker than his thumb and not quite as long as his forearm, but when held in the hand it glowed as brightly as a lantern. Lightsticks shattered like glass, too; he had nearly lost Spray in the fire caused by the first he had owned. A small, age-dark ivory carving of a man holding a sword. The fellow who sold it claimed if you held it long enough you started to feel warm. Domon never had, and neither had any of the crew he let hold it, but it was old, and that was enough for Domon.” (TITLE: Great Hunt, CHAPTER: 9 - Leavetakings)
“The fellow who sold it” was obviously a man who could be taught to channel or who had the spark, though most likely he did not know that himself.
Coincidentally all the 'ivory' angreal are also 'age-darkened' like Elayne's bronze statue, though that probably is too weak a similarity to be of importance. It does however give an indication that the statue is very old, and a male angreal has to be over 3000 years old.
But what I mean is; could Elayne's man be the (sa')angreal Lanfear is referring to? In the same chapter where she finds it Elayne thinks to herself, a little later; “...but most angreal were small enough to carry about your person; not all, but most.” The phrasing suggests a typical Jordanesque 'nonquote'; when using "most are/were" or "almost every is/was" Jordan usually means "but you'll be confronted with one that isn't soon".
Some more quotes to make it likely there's an angreal in the Ebou Dar stash:
Sammael apparantly was searching for a cache of angreal in Ebou Dar, so that is at least some indication that there COULD be male angreal between the Kin's stash;
"I [Sammael] all but have my hands on a cache of angreal and who can say what else.” (This in conversation with Graendal. TITLE: Lord of Chaos, CHAPTER: 23 - To Understand a Message)
“"No," Sammael said finally. “Your search is the most important thing, the only thing, so far as you are concerned.” ” (To Carridin (Bors) in Ebou Dar. TITLE: Crown of Swords, CHAPTER: 15 -Insects)
Moridin's remarks;
“From behind a screen of white wrought iron, Moridin watched the last of the horses vanish through the gateway, and then the tall young woman and the four Warders. It was possible they were carrying away some item he could use—an angreal attuned to men, perhaps—but the chances were small.”... “Sammael was a fool to have risked so much to seize a collection of no one knew what, then, Sammael had never been half as clever as he thought." (TITLE: Path of Daggers, CHAPTER: 2 - Unweaving)
Apart from Sammael, even Moridin thought there might be male angreal in the Ebou Dar stash. So did Moghedien by the way;
“Months of futile search had convinced her [Falion Bhoda] there was no cache of angreal, whatever Moghedien believed. She had even considered putting a Wise Woman or two to the question; one of them might know its whereabouts, if it existed.” (Moghedien did not work for Moridin yet at this point. TITLE: Lord of Chaos, CHAPTER: EPILOGUE)
So that's basically it; Sammael was looking for angreal in Ebou Dar, Elayne finds a rather large statuette of a man, angreal often look like the sex they're attuned to, and Lanfear remarks that two angreal are stronger than Callandor that a man can use. (for the sake of RSI, I'm using angreal/sa'angreal freely)
You cannot rate theories without first logging in. Please
log in.
1
Tamyrlin: 2003-04-04
Actually, this is a good idea. It is possible that what the statue seen was the other male sa'angreal. Jordan foreshadowed its discovery with Lanfear's remarks. I think the important distinction happens to be in the difference between sa'angreal and angreal. Do we know of any sa'angreal that can fit in your pocket? None that I remember hearing of, so I think a case can be made for size between angreal and sa'angreal.
2
Weird Harold: 2003-04-04
I don't know how Rand got it from Domon, but, "A small, age-dark ivory carving of a man holding a sword." Is the description of the "fat man" angral Rand was looking for after Dumai's wells. (I think Taim has it now.)
At one point, Rand clutches the "fat man" angreal so tight the sword drew blood from his hand.
Good spot on the statue Elayne found in the Ebou Dar stash. It may not be the missing second most powerful Sa'angral, but it's definitely a male angreal of considerable power.
3
Callandor: 2003-04-04
Rand found his angreal in the Stone of Tears cache.
Personally, Ive always ranked Callandor as the second most powerful sa'angreal of all time, havent had much time with any others, but I like the idea that Elayne has the possiblity to have this sa angreal, if it is, in her possession.
And yeah, that statue Damon had, guaranteed was an angreal at least.
4
believer2: 2003-04-09
What about the 'Nine Rods of Dominion' mentioned by Elan Morin (Issy) in the prologue of EotW. The way he said it to LTT 'Once you summoned the Nine Rods of Dominion' makes it sound rather important.
I believe (no proof) that the Oath Rod is one of the nine.
5
WinespringBrother: 2003-04-10
It's probably an angreal or sa'angreal, however, it was also left behind by Sammael's treasure hunters. Now if Lanfear heard of this device, surely Sammael did also, and would have had his crew make sure to find and remove it. They obviously got some things, such as the oath rod, and Sammael would have had them target "the second most powerful sa'angreal" made for men. Although his minions may just be incompetent or somehow overlooked it.
My guess for the second most powerful sa'angreal is the Ring of Tamyrlin, which we know little about except that it belonged to LTT, but at least it was named, and there has to be some reason for its existence :)
6
Daishan: 2003-04-10
I actually think Sammael got his oath rod from his own stasis box. Besides, the men Sammael sent obviously couldn't channel so they wouldn't know just every male angreal on sight. It's possible Sammael gave a description of something he was looking for, although considering the number of ter'angreal and angreal in existence that sounds unlikely. I somehow don't think the Ring of Tamyrlin isn't the angreal Lanfear was referring to. It might even be Egwene's/Elayne's/Nynaeve's dream ring.
7
Callandor: 2003-04-10
The two more powerful are most likely the statue or the Ring of Tam. The dream ring I dont think is the Ring of Tam but thats just my own opinion. I also thing that the Ring will most likely come back to play a role some how weather important or not.
And the Oath Rod is not a Rod of Dominion. It, along with the one Galima was bound with, is one of many binders from the AoL which criminals that could channel were bound so they couldnt commit that crime.
8
Ven: 2003-04-09
I heard some speculation recently that the second most powerful male sa'angreal was the Seanchan Crystal Throne. If this is the case it seems likely at least one of the Forsaken would have recognized it--especially if Semirhage is Anath.
9
Daishan: 2003-04-12
This is highly unlikely. Not only is there no evidence to support it, there is also evidence that support the other, more common belief; that the Crystal Throne is a ter'angreal that uses some form of compulsion on the ones that come near it, to make them feel a sense of awe and obedience towards the one that is on it.
I agree that the "Ring of Tamyrlin" COULD, I repeat, COULD be the "second most powerful (sa')angreal", but again, there is no evidence. The only "evidence" is that Lews Therin Telamon appearantly wore it "once upon a time". This in itself does not mean in any way that it is an angreal. It could be a ter'angreal, maybe even one like the Crystal Throne (lol). I think I have made a rather compelling argument in the theory above on why it is likely there is a male (sa')angreal of considerable strength, in Elayne's Ebou Dar stash. I have also made the argument on how the "second most powerful angreal" will likely be bigger than most of the angreal we've seen so far (Rand's, Moiraine's, Domon's, Elayne's, Graendal's, Verin's, etc., etc.) so combined with Lanfear's/Jordan's foreshadowing and all the quotes what more do you need?
Of course, no-one HAS to agree ;)
But if you do, please the faction I recently created concerning this subject.
10
Jiana: 2003-04-12
Yes, the "fat little man" angreal (which I think probably resembles Buddah somewhat) was found in the Stone of Tear, and has the sword lying across his knees; he is not holding it. Domon's "statue" was holding the sword. It is very likely that the Crystal Throne is a sa'angreal, however it can't be one attuned to men because the Seanchan murder all their men who can channel. The "bronze statue" Elayne found, I believe is an excellent candidate. What about the red crystal chair that was found, oh I can't remember exactly, but I think it was in Rhuidean? Even if this is not the other "more powerful" male sa'angreal, it is likely one of the things Sammael called "a binding chair" in one of his conversations with Graendal. This leads me to believe, that in the AoL, the rods were not the only binders that were used. Perhaps the rods were only for use for men and women who could channel, and the chair(s) were for use with men and women who could not. Just a thought. :)
11
Anubis: 2003-04-12
i dont think so. for one, there is no evidence toward this. i think that its possible that the throne is a ter angreal seeing as everyone who sees the throne feels immense awe and all.
12
Callandor: 2003-04-12
BWB, Chapter 17, Seanchan, page 160:
**The Crystal Throne itself is a great ter angreal that causes anyone who approaches it to feel immense awe and wonder. Of course, only the reigning monarch is ever allowed to use it.**
Crystal Throne is a ter angreal not a male selected sa angreal.
13
Weird Harold: 2003-04-18
An interesting find in tDR Ch 29,"A Trap to Spring" (pg 337 in the Tor PB edition):
Siuan Sanche to Nyneave about Callandor, "It's a Sa'angreal. Only two more powerful were ever made and thankfully they were never used."
And, a moment later, "With Callandor in your hands, child, you could level a city with one blow."
This is obviously another example of Aes Sedai ignorance and arrogance, because from the context it's apparent that SS believes the two Chodean Kal statues are the "two more powerful" and that Callandor can be used by a woman.
(Maybe Callandor can be used by a woman despite Cadsuane's assertion that it needs a link circle of two women and one man to be used safely.)
14
Callandor: 2003-04-18
Only way that Callandor could be used by a woman is like in WH at the Cleansing. Man has to go into a link and 2 women have to link with him and one has to control the flows. Otherwise it is a purely male sa angreal. Same goes for female angreal and sa angreal being useless by men unless in a link.
15
araqyl: 2003-05-16
There is no evidence that I can recall that the Ring of Tamyrlin had any power at all - it could simply have been an ordinary ring that was an item of regalia identifying the leader of the Hall of the Servants. Subtle enough that it didn't draw attention (like a crown would have), but still indicating position.
16
heronblade: 2003-06-05
i like weird harold's idea. it does sound from that quote that SS is genereralising between male and female attuned sa'. SS could well be ref to the 2 CK statues but i cant belive LF was. "There are only two more powerful that a man can use." Shadow Rising, CHAPTER: 9. she specifies male attunement, though she does concede one may not have survived so we might not run into the second. unlikely knowing rj
17
anderwarrick: 2003-06-05
I think when Siuan said that with it you could level a city in one blow, is that a man wielding it could level a city in one blow. It is accepeted by all(well maybe a few dont) that angreal and sa'angreal have to either be male or female. So i dont think that Siuan was saying that a female channeler could wield it. Except for the linking thing.
18
The Leveler: 2003-06-06
Someone mentioned the Crystal Throne. I also belive that it is a ter'angreal, but that it is a binding chair. One of the Forsaken mentioned binding chairs were used to control people who couldn't channel. And I think the exact quote was "find their mouths dry with the desire to obey". Pretty clear that it's a binding chair. And I know that Bindings are permanent and shorten your life, but if you didn't quite know how to use it...
19
anderwarrick: 2003-06-06
I think its in the BWB or maybe in WH, when we get Tuons pov, that it says that the crystal throne is a ter'angreal that makes the people standing/kneeling whatever near it to be in awe of it and the person sitting in it. I also think i heard somewhere, maybe in a theory that it might have been the tamyrlin's chair.
20
Callandor: 2003-06-06
Read all post before sumbitting. The Crystal Throne is a ter angreal that inspires immense awe. Its in the BWB and quoted in the above posts.
21
Rhodric: 2003-06-30
Daishan, you said
"While not on a one-to-one scale, size does appear to matter somewhat regarding the strength of angreal/sa'angreal."
yes, its mostly true. but the sa'angreal that was used to separate mat from the dagger was a foot long ebony rod. small, but powerful. (i might be wrong - don't have the quote)
personally i think that if this super powerful sa'angreal exists, it is in Rhuidean. of the forsaken, only Lanfear and Asmodean know anything about the place, possibly now Moridin, since Lanfear/Cyndane is under the thumb.
And look at all the weird stuff in there! Look at it! ;p
22
Rhodric: 2003-07-01
oops it should say foot long IVORY rod, not ebony.
i always get those two mixed up.
23
Memnochssoul: 2003-07-05
maybe lanfear was referring to the keys that access the Choedan Kal, i know that they are really ter'angrel that buffer the connection to the sa'angrel but its might be that she was talking about the two male access keys (i think there are two, there are two female i'm pretty sure, the one rand found at rhuidian, and the broken one in tanchio)
24
Daishan: 2003-07-29
It's not certain at that point that Lanfear knows about the survival of one of the male Access Keys. Rand has not yet shown any intention of going into the Aiel waste and it seems from later information that both Lanfear and Asmodean only went there to explore AFTER Rand chose direction. Also, in the "The Strike at Shayol Ghul" ( http://www.tor.com/shayol.html ) it is mentioned that;
"According to the manuscript pages, all of the agents responsible for this smuggling [smuggling of the access ter'angreal] were caught, though that was not known until events had far outrun anyone's plans. They were brave men and women, for although those who were not killed outright were tortured, and though some revealed the purpose of their mission, none betrayed the location of any of the access ter'angreal. Still, the only real result was that the ter'angreal were widely scattered across areas held for the Shadow, their locations and even their existence to remain hidden for millennia."
Which, in my view, means there were quite a number of keys. "Scattered over a wide area" doesn't suggest 2 or even 4 keys. So why would Lanfear then mention "2 more powerful"?
25
Tamyrlin: 2003-07-30
Lanfear talks about two more powerful sa'angreal; the keys are ter'angreal. Obviously, the male statue is one of the two more powerful sa'angreal, and so we are left with one unknown sa'angreal that is more powerful than Callandor that males can use, which has nothing to do with the statue or the keys.
26
juitzhead: 2003-07-30
Well, since there are 2 female access keys, the one in the Panarch palace (which was broken) and the one in rhuidean, this would suggest that there were also 2 male access keys.
quote:
"Lews Therin has two of the access keys, one for each. And he knows a woman strong enough to use the female of the pair. He plans to use the Choedan Kal for his deed." - WH
Cyndane mentions 'two of' which means there are more than one.
27
Daishan: 2003-07-30
Juitzhead, my point was that there are likely MORE Access Keys than just the two for each, because of the "scattered over a wide area" quote. It's nowhere mentioned that there were only 2 female keys EVER. Perhaps as much as 4 or 6 or 8 were made.
However, Tamyrlin has argued my point even better, helpfully pointing out that the Keys are indeed ter'angrael, not sa'angreal. Maybe you should think of joining my faction, Tam :)
28
Dovien: 2010-08-11
That a great male sa'angreal exists in Rhuidean seems the most likely at this point. I've always had a pet theory, though, that the sa'angreal being referred to is one of the spikes mentioned in the books.
Off the top of my head I remember Bayle Domon's story about how the wonder of the world pulls people out to adventure. He mentions a tall spike in the Borderlands which is said to kill anyone who comes within 50 feet. I'm sure there's another mention of a large spike artifact somewhere too.